Rock Bands as Holy Spirit

BeatlesRowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, recently weighed in again, this time with a profound thought that “Beatles songs are as likely to explain Christianity as the Bible.” In an endorsement of Finding Faith, a book written by Rt Rev Nick Baines, Bishop of Croydon, Williams says, “For many people the language of the Bible has become inaccessible and yet pop song writers can make a connection with people because their language is fresh.”

Essentially equating rock bands with the Holy Spirit, he says, “They [rock music] are able to open our imagination to a way of thinking about God that we’ve become deaf to in church language.”

Some of the songs mentioned in the book are composed and sung by such Christian stalwarts such as Eric Clapton, Bob Dylan, John Lennon (“We’re more famous than Jesus Christ”), Bruce Cockburn and U2.

Williams says about pop groups’ influence on his “faith,” “I have read the Bible through many times and I have enjoyed art all over the world… But it was a simple song from [Bruce] Cockburn’s early period that gave me the words to hang all this together…” He wonders how it took a U2 song to help him define his faith, “What I can’t quite understand is why it took a song by an Irish rock band to make me identify what I actually felt about being a Christian in a complicated world.”

It would seem that the eminent Archbishop thinks that rock groups have been commissioned by the Holy Spirit to take over His work of regenerating human hearts. Many Christians would be appalled with Williams’ pronouncements, but his sayings are the same things we hear very often in modern evangelicalism. They would not even blink in arguing that churches should use rock music and other “creative” entertainment gimmicks in “appealing to non-churchgoers” so they would be saved.

The ordinary means of grace, preaching of the gospel and the sacraments? They’re obsolete, says Williams. It would then be just a matter of time before we’re all singing George Harrison’s “My Sweet Lord” on the Lord’s Day.1

1 Several years ago, my wife once went to a Christmas Eve “worship” where the worship team led the congregation in singing “Feliz Navidad” and “La Bamba.”


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

3 thoughts on “Rock Bands as Holy Spirit”

  1. @Nollie: This truly is a sad state of affairs.  A faulty view of the Word of God has corrupted church services, evangelism, apologetics…and the list goes on.

    As you’ve said, the Archbishop’s words may seem ‘incredible’, but he is simply being consistent with the modern evangelicalism’s practice.

  2. rafael t. martinez

    Dear Pastor Nollie,

    Your observation regarding the entertainment gimmicks of those who are claiming to be Christians is correct. They believe that their music can save just because it attracts people especially young people. What they do not know( I am not really sure if these people really do not know or they are just suffering from delusion that they believe the lie being fed on them by satan) however is that the Bible teaches that there are only two means of grace and these are, the preaching of the Word and the Sacraments.
    Obviously, Archbishop Williams and those people who believe that their music which was copied from the “world” can save and therefore, the Holy Spirit himself, are teaching another gospel. These people should, as the apostle Paul said in Romans 16:17, be avoided.


  3. arthur tazal manglicmot aka "atto"

    how true kuya noli, i am appaled by the thought that these rock groups have replaced the preachers in making the world know the gospel. but come to think of it, maybe its an eye-opener for nominal  Christians to weigh the seriousness of not being serious with the bible. maybe they dont know the difference because they dont know their bibles too! When John Lennon said those words he is just letting us know that we have exchange GOD for an idol. i am a Beatles fan and though i like them in my youth i do not like all their lyrics. Correction, it was George Harrison who wrote the “My Sweet Lord” song where in the end the Lord he is referring to is not Jesus Christ but Khrisna as he ends it with some sort of incantation. Nice of you to share us these things.  atto m.

Comments are closed.

Related Posts

From Psalms to Hymns to Rock Bands to …

The theological erosion of worship music is even worse when “contemporary” music arrived. These songs were written by mostly Biblically- and theologically-illiterate young men and women, even those in their early teens!

Are You a Frog in the Kettle?

Soon they will realize either that their faith in Christ is being challenged and will therefore seek a true church or, like the frog in the kettle, they may remain as their profession of faith is increasingly confused, weakened, and perhaps even abandoned.