I learned another contemporary worship song this last weekend, “In Christ Alone,” words and music by Keith Getty & Stuart Townend (Â©Â 2001 Kingsway Thankyou Music). Overall, I liked most of the lyrics, and the music as well. It has the gospel: Christ’s birth, life, death resurrection and return. It actually sounds like a creedal song.
Having said that, as a Reformed pastor, I will not use it for worship or teaching. Why? First, it has hints of Arminian theology:
Did the authors write “ev’ry sin on Him was laid” to mean that Jesus died for the sins of all human beings, or in the sense of 1 John 2:2, “for the sins of the whole world?”
Second, just like most contemporary worship music, the theology of glory is hinted and maybe even evidenced in these words:
Finally, and this is ironicâ€”the authors are probably Arminian, and almost all evangelicals love this songâ€”a few lines advocate the Reformed doctrine of the preservation and perseverance of the saints, which most Arminians hate together with all things Reformed:
This last point says a lot about the attitude of evangelicals concerning what they sing, which is, â€œI donâ€™t know and I donâ€™t care, as long as it moves me to sway and dance, or close my eyes and shed tears.â€
Years ago, I was told by one of my high school students in Davao that their Pentecostal Bible study teacher told them that Calvin was wrong on this doctrine. The first two lines above allude to John 10:28-29:
The teacher said that even if no one is able to pluck a believer out of God’s hand, that same believer may jump out of God’s hand if he wills to do so. Human “free will” rocks! Human “free will” reigns! Jesus was just kidding when he said, “My Father… is greater than all.” Just utter stupidity and foolishness!
For those who are wondering what this “perseveance” doctrine is all about, Tabletalk magazine has a series of devotionals on Hebrews 6:4-6, “one of the most difficult passages in all of Scripture,” which “has often been used with the attempt to prove that genuine Christians can lose their salvation.” No, this is not “once saved, always saved.” Not even “eternal security.”
To find out, here are the links to the series, verses 4-10:
“Impossible to Restore” (verse 4a)
“The Covenant Community” (verses 4b-5)
“Those Who Fall Away” (verse 6)
“A Good Crop” (verses 7-8)
“Sure of Better Things” (verses 9)
“God Remembers Us” (verse 10)
To download all of the above in one printer-friendly PDF document, click here.